Home

HUDOC User Manual 1.0

1. 25 J UT 26 Domestic LaW ee ee VIE Nia V 26 International Law amp Other Relevant Material 26 M OES C 26 N Search in document 27 VII How to sort your results 28 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights VIII THE results list Screen said iai Rc M RECHNER HR RB TERR E RR 29 A Viewing search esl Ss svetqipTES i trvPERISEIIA SERIA DN OU ITE qiu V EF MET PUPEIIEITRPEPGUEPTUEICN 30 1 ais RENI ITII 31 2 EXPO MH E E E E 31 3 Pio PARAE EEA P E A AE E EE 31 B Viewing dOCUMEentS ss ssssssrsrrrrnrsrsrrnrnrrnrnrnrrrenrnrnnrnrnrnnenenrnrnnrnenrnrenerrnrnnrnn 31 l Viewing a document in web HTML format 31 2 Opening and downloading the PDF version of the original document 32 35 Opening and downloading a Word copy of the original document 32 4 DOCUMEN URL rem 33 5 Maximising and minimising the view of the document 33 6 Sending a link to ths docBEiellE cespuspmisEFEOS
2. 33 7 Printing the doce da XE da Ud 33 Viewing the Case NS rc 33 D Viewing Language VelsloFiSssuexadexausdtad des vu nda ra dad Vui curvas ua EN sual PIE Cau 34 E Viewing Related bac UR GO Ge UR taU OUR Rd dA 35 F Viewing the Legal 58 5 5 5 boned 36 VIEWING Press UR AUR ER ROUND MA ACER RR 40 IX UNG LOOSE wd E tQ i C Un D 45 A uz m 45 HUDOC eee ERE About the database The European Court of Human Rights ECHR Portal is a powerful modern user friendly information system The HUDOC database provides access to the case law of the European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber Chamber and Committee judgments decisions communicated cases advisory opinions and legal summaries from the Case Law Information Note the European Commission of Human Rights decisions and reports and the Committee of Ministers resolutions These texts can be consulted via a sophisticated yet easy to use search screen To ensure the most efficient use of the database as a research tool the Portal is updated regularly II Interface languages The Portal is available in English and French interfaces HUDOC Pe Advance Searc European Cou
3. EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS gt COUR EUROPEENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME HUDOC User Manual HUDOC European Court of Human Rights COUNCIL OF EUROPE CONSEIL DE L EUROPE HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Contents About the database csse nnnnuuuuhuuRRuRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRARRRRRRRRRRRARRES 4 Il Interface languages vssss ui iwRaic i pi OR SdoREE RN GR OR RCRUM DR RH 4 III Document collection c ne hnnnhhnuuuhuuuhhuuuuuuRRuRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR 5 IV MENU NEU LMEI 6 A 6 Simple Boolean Search screen x ER EC a RENT ee teense 7 Word SUCCES ONCE e 8 V Narrowing your Search sedsasuiddumia nadu nad AVR Ban SUME Mo SCR EE a RR 9 A B LRCERTTITECNEr m 9 1 aron UT TT Terr 10 2 IDOL C ET 11 What we mean by texts analysed by importance level 12 3 w FDLBCTTTTTTTTTRRERTRPREN 12 4 ji guis TENOR 13 5 NOn VIO 218 9 RECTE TETUER 14 6 14 0 06 15 ERUIT 18 1 BLUE adancsae ne niantaniaedaaea nea s
4. To confirm the selection of language s You can sort the Language filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order 2 Importance The Importance filter can be used to make searches of judgments decisions and or advisory opinions classified by level of importance Cases are divided into four categories the highest level of importance being Case Reports followed by levels 1 2 and 3 The classification by levels 1 2 and 3 remains provisional until the Bureau has decided whether a case should appear in the Court s official reports series These Bureau decisions are published on the Court s website under Case Law For example a case that was tentatively classified as level 1 but ultimately selected for the official reports will change category Case Reports Judgments decisions and advisory opinions delivered since the inception of the new Court in 1998 which have been published or selected for publication in the Court s official Reports of Judgments and Decisions The selection from 2007 onwards has been made by the Bureau of the Court following a proposal by the Jurisconsult Judgments of the former Court published in Series A and Reports and cases published in the former Commission s Decisions and Reports series have not been included in the Case Reports category and are therefore classified by levels 1 2 and 3 only 1 High importance
5. Detsils Legs Summary Language Versions Fress Release Related HTML format You will be able to read the text by scrolling down and up maximise and minimise the window send a link to the document print the document download the PDF version of the document download the original Word version of the document see the previous and the next terms searched for in the document go to the previous and next documents in the results list and obtain the document URL 31 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Click to print the CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY d ocument 1473709 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Second Section 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echy coe int sites eng pages search aspxs itemid 001 105624 Case Details Translation Relat View maximised minimised Document URL Click to download the PDF version of the document Click on these Click to send a Click to buttons to see the link to the download the previous next document original Word terms searched for EUR 1 lt version of in the document COUR E the previous the P document 4 document SECOND SECTION Click here to view Web HTML the next document CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY Click here to view version of the document Application no 14737 09 Scroll down and up Searched term highlighted in
6. GRUYKIN Bulgaria 31 05 2012 Remainder inadmissible Violation of Article 1 of Protocol No 1 Protection of property Article 1 para 1 of Protocol No 1 Peaceful enjoyment of possessions Possessions Violation of Article 13 Right to an effective remedy Article 13 Effective remedy Pecuniary and non pecuniary damage award 13 35 41 46 46 2 No Ashingdane v the United Kingdom 28 May 1985 5 57 Series A no 93 Burdov v Russia 2 33509 04 5 99 ECHR 2009 Broniowski v Poland GC no 31443 96 ECHR 2004 V Brumarescu v Romania just satisfaction GC no 28342 95 5 20 ECHR 2000 1 D Viewing Language Versions CASE OF KLAAS v GERMANY 15473 89 Judgment Merits Court Chamber 22 09 1993 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 001 57826 View Case Details Language Versions Related Language versions Official Languages Judgments decisions and other texts are available in HUDOC i English French Official translations in English and or French Non official translations Disclaimer HUDOC European Court of Human Rights By clicking on Language Versions you will be directed to a page giving you access to any translations of the case available in the official languages English and French Translations into non official languages are not made by the Registry of the Court and it does not check their accuracy or linguistic quality The
7. liil Bosnia and Herzegovina http w w w mhrr gov ba ured zastupnika odluke id 170 http w w w coe ba web index php optionzcom content amp tasksview amp id 43 amp ltemid 34 E Viewing Related documents Click on Related to be directed to other documents specifically related to the document you are currently viewing CASE OF BRAUER v GERMANY 3545 04 Judgment Merits Court Fifth Section 28 05 2009 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 001 92752 View Case Details Language Versions Related Related Related English Documents Chamber Judgments CASE OF BRAUER v GERMANY Legal Summaries Brauer v Germany Press Releases Related English and or Chamber judgments 28 01 10 Announce judgments 26 28 01 10 Fre n C h d OCU m e n ts Chamber judgment Brauer v Germany 28 05 2009 Announce judgments 26 28 05 09 Related French Documents Chamber Judgments AFFAIRE BRAUER c ALLEMAGNE AFFAIRE BRAUER c ALLEMAGNE Legal Summaries Brauer c Allemagne Press Releases Arr ts de chambre 28 01 10 Annonce arr ts 26 28 01 10 Arr t de chambre Brauer c Allemagne 28 05 09 Annonce 26 28 05 09 Possible uses of this function include the following Related English Documents Judgments decisions communicated cases reports resolutions Legal summaries 35 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Press releases Related French Documents Judgments d
8. swimming pool and Russian language classes could in no way compensate for the child s drastic immersion in a linguistically and culturally foreign environment and external psychological support could not be considered equivalent to the support intrinsic to strong stable and undisturbed ties between a child and its mother Nor had the Italian courts considered any alternative solutions for ensuring contact between the boy and his father The interference had thus not been necessary in a democratic society Conclusion violation six votes to one b Procedura faimess Taking into account that both the father and the first applicant had submitted with the aid of counsel detailed written statements to two levels of Italian jurisdiction the Court like the European Commission was satisfied that the procedural fairness requirement of Article 8 had been observed Conclusion no violation unanimously Article 41 EUR 10 000 jointly in respect of non pecuniary damage Whilst it contains no explicit procedural requirements Article 8 requires that the decisiq erence must be fair and such as to afford due respect to the interests safeguarded by that Article Link to the Case Law Information Notes Council of Europe European Court of Human Righjz This summary by the Registry does not bind the Click here for the Case Law Information Motes You can receive the Information Notes automatically by subscribing to the Court s RSS feed h
9. 06 2012 Last 6 Months Related 573 215 Cialcec Last Year os 1067 w Arr t de Grande Chambre Kuric et autres c Slov nie 26 06 2012 Last 5 Years Communiqu de presse Arr ts de grande chambre Published On 26 06 2012 4854 Details Related Last 10 Years 7400 Chamber Judgments of 26 06 12 HUDOC Collection Press Release Chamber Judgments Published 26 06 2012 MORE FILTERS Details Related JUDGES ORGANISATIONS Jean Paul Costa European Court Forthcoming Chamber Judgments 3 5 07 2012 Coste a 588 of Press Release Forthcoming Judgments Published 26 06 2012 Francoise Rights 4271 eae Tulkens 1461 Council of Details Related Nicolas Bratza Europe 3529 1426 European w Arr t de chambre Piruzyan c Arm nie 26 06 12 Commission Communiqu de presse Arr ts de chambre Published On 26 06 2012 Christos Council of Europe European Court of Human Rights Case Law Analysis Privacy Help Back toto p You can carry out a keyword search filter your search by Language State Document and Date and apply more filters such as Judges or Organisation The functionalities of this database are the same as for the HUDOC Collection 43 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights You can also find the Press Collection via the links on the Court s homepage n IT rag EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COUR
10. 2 741 Russian 38 1 409 Polish B Case Heports More 182 More Italy 609 B 2598 Ukraine 345 6 1 2598 Russia 255 41 1810 Romania 243 P1 1 1484 More More HON VIOLATION VIOLATION 5 265 6 1954 6 1 231 8 1 1900 Number of documents 3 48 e 85 More More You can very easily narrow your search using the filters The results screen will be modified each time you use a filter Your chosen filters will be listed in the criteria bar Example Judgments Grand Chamber and Chamber Language English Importance 1 State United Kingdom Non violation of Article 8 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights HUDOC Number of results Fete pee European Court of Human Rights 1 ONADES sseweres Clear all criteria DOCUMENT COLLECTIONS El Iv Case Law 31 CRITERIA Document Collection 0 Committee Decisions Language English x Importance lgyel 1 Judgments 31 E Export RSS Sort by Relevance v Criteria v Grand Chamber 11 Respondent State United Kingdom Non violation 8 ba r Chamber 20 Remove this Committee 0 H CASE OF v THE UNITED KINGDOM fi Iter by Decisions 0 56328 07 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fourth Section 27 Admissibility 0 No violation of Art 14 8 Screening Panel 0 clicking on x Comes dii Case Details Legal Summary
11. EUROPEENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME Site map 2 Contact Disclaimer Privacy News The Court Grand Chamber judgments 26 06 2012 Case Law The Court delivered two Grand Chamber judgments In the case of Herrmann v Germany the Court held that the abligation to tolerate hunting an their property imposed a disproportionate burden on landawners in Germany who were 43 for ethical reasons The Court thereby in two previous judgments concerning In France and Luxembourg Information sheets Reports Pending Cases Press h Applicants Ls Visitors Multimedia E i Ewents at the Court El Multimedia mE Releases Library EM nidis o Recent press Link to the Press focesure the releases lomestic compensa Releases in of all similar apy Council of Europe Press site Calendar of E hearings A Hearing of 06 07 2011 Web TV ch Webcasts af hearings Grand Chamber New technologies Cases pending Referral New HUDOC database before the Grand 27 06 2012 26 06 2012 Chamber The Court has accepted the referral to the A new version of Grand Chamber of the case X v Latvia J Hudec the Case Law F H U D OC Court s case law Information Notes v Press Release European Court of Human Rights 029 se is on line This more intuitive search
12. Translation Related z Pema CASE OF MOSLEY v THE UNITED KINGDOM Reports 0 48008 08 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fourth Section 10 05 2011 Resolutions 0 No violation of Art 8 Execution 0 Case Details Legal Summary Translation Related Merits 0 Press Collection QEK D NITED KINGDOM FILTERS Remove this Court Fourth Section 18 05 2010 LANGUAGE IMPORTANCE s and dismissed victim No violation of Art 8 No violation of Art 6 1 No violation of more English 31 x 1 31 x filter by tion Related n clicking on 9 ED KINGDOM More 6339 05 Judgment Merits Court Grand Chamber 10 04 2007 STATE ARTICLE L of 2 violation of Art 5 No violation of Art 14 United Kingdom x 31 Filter reduced to the choice DF R K AND A K v THE UNITED KINGDOM made Available only in English Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fourth Section 30 09 2008 HON VIOLATION of Art 8 Violation of Art 13 Non pecuniary damage award 8 31 13 3 csse Details Legal Summary Related 14 14 6 2 8 7 4 2 CASE OF HATTON AND OTHERS v THE UNITED KINGDOM 1448 7 6 1 2 6 7 8 2 20222020 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Grand Chamber 08 07 2003 More of Art amp Violation of Art 13 Non pecuniary damage finding of violation sufficient
13. an RSS feed for the criteria used in your search You can personalise your RSS feed and be informed of recent documents concerning the subject you are interested in For example if you have searched for all judgments Grand Chamber and Chamber in English Importance 1 State United Kingdom you will create an RSS feed for these criteria and will be sent links to related content on the Internet site In order to read and use these feeds you need a news reader This is a piece of software that checks the feeds and lets you read any new articles that have been added There are many different news readers available a large number can be found using an Internet search engine Once you have installed a news reader you can subscribe to the feeds B Viewing documents You can view documents in one of 3 ways View the document in HTML format Open and download the PDF version of the original document Open and download a Word copy of the original document 1 Viewing a document in web HTML format Click on the case title to open the viewing window 0 CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY 14737 08 Judgment Meritt and Just Satisfaction Court Sens Click here to show rir Oe Tn anm nmm darent ia 1 0 rene i Selec remedies the document in DT AM In
14. document To print the document simply click on the print icon in the viewing window C Viewing the Case Details The Case Details link provides information associated with each document in the HUDOC collection and gives a brief overview of the scope of the case The information under Case Details includes basic data such as Title Date State etc as well as more specific legal data such as Keywords Strasbourg Case Law Domestic Law International Law amp Other Relevant Material Rules of Court etc Originating Body Document Type Language s Title Application Number s Importance Level Respondent State s Date of Judgment Applicability Conclusion s Rules of Court Separate Opinion s Domestic Law Strasbourg Case Law International Law and Other Relevant Material Keywords 33 HUDOC Manual CASE OF VASILEV AND DOYCHEVA v BULGARIA 14966 04 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fourth Section 31 05 2012 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 001 111203 View Case Details Originating Body Document Type Language s Title App No s Importance Level Represented by Respondent State s Judgment Date Conclusion s Article s Separate Opinion s Strasbourg Case Law Translation Related Court Fourth Section Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction FRENCH CASE OF VASILEV AND DOYCHEVA v BULGARIA 14966 04 1
15. green The Web HTML version of the document is presented in Arial font for ease of reading 2 Opening and downloading the PDF version of the original document To open and download the PDF version of the document simply click on the PDF icon 2 in the viewing window 3 Opening and downloading a Word copy of the original document You can also open a copy of the original document directly in your word processor or text editor As the formatting of a document is different when viewed in an Internet browser this function is particularly useful for those who want to peruse a document in its original layout Not only will the database open up an original version of the file for you but this will enable you to cut copy and paste more easily To open and download the original version of the document simply click on the Word icon e in the viewing window 32 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights From the viewing window you can also access 4 Document URL This is the unique link otherwise known as a URL to the document You can bookmark this link or copy it to a separate document in order to quickly and easily access documents of interest to you 5 Maximising and minimising the view of the document TO maximise and minimise the viewing window simply click on the icon 6 Sending a link to the document To send a link to the document simply click on the mail icon in the viewing window 7 Printing the
16. the Case Details below page 33 M Keywords The legal issues dealt with in each case are summarised in a list of Keywords chosen from a thesaurus of terms taken in most cases directly from the text of the European Convention on Human Rights and additional Protocols Searching with these keywords will enable you to find a group of documents with similar legal content keywords are linked to the Court s reasoning and its conclusions To enter a keyword you should open the lookup by clicking on the button 26 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights A list of keywords will be displayed in chronological order of the Articles of the Convention and additional Protocols All information concerning keywords by Articles can be found on page 13 2 Keywords You can select one or more keywords by the box to the left of the keyword Once you have made your selection click on the button to confirm The window will then close and the selected keyword s will appear on the search screen e g Keyword Art 10 1 Freedom of express _ You can then perform a search for all documents which contain those keywords NOTE You cannot add modify or delete keywords directly from the search screen You must open and use the Keyword window instead TIP To view the list of keywords associated with a case from the HUDOC case law collection open the Case Details page for more information see Viewing the Case Details
17. will be available in the coming weeks HUDOC help HUDOC Collections Useful links Help HUDOC database Privacy User manual and Video tutorials Case law Information Notes RSS FAQ Press releases European Court of Human Rights Language versions Council of Europe Keywords by Article Description of the Collections Execution of Judgments Note on citation Committee of Ministers Compatible browsers 71 H L man Right At the end of the page you have a navigator which gives you access to HUDOC help the HUDOC Collection and Useful links 46
18. 031011 12011 to 10 05 2012 Application Number ERG V Bloc E Strasbourg Rules af Court Applicability Mather Relevant Material Keywords Art 2 1 Life In this example the search has been focused on the word prison Text field from 03 01 2011 to 10 05 2012 Date and Art 2 1 Life Keyword A Text Use the Text field to perform a free text search in one or more collections Entering terms in the Text box carries out a search for a particular item in the main text of a document whether it be a single word a phrase a sentence etc In addition to the simple search defined above you can use the Portal to carry out much more complex searches TIP More information concerning Text search can be found in the Search Syntax and Simple Boolean Search Screen sections under Simple Search page 5 and 6 B Case Title Use the Case Title field to search by the name of the case Type any part of the case title in the box and click on the case you are looking for from the list of suggestions Examples boulois hatton Case Title baulais CASE OF BOULOIS v LUXEMBOURG Strasbourg Case Law l Boulois c Luxembourg Rules af Court Boulois c Luxembourg GC T Boulois v Luxembourg Applicability Boulois v Luxembourg GC 21 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights C Application Number Use the Application Number field to search by th
19. 15 03 2012 Ae Originating CASE OF S H AND OTHERS v AUSTRIA 5781500 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Grand Chamber 03 11 2011 of domestic remedies No violation of Art 8 Fress Release alatez Case Details UGAL to see the hent Cour Second Section 31 01 2012 profile igzible Violation of Art 6 1 No violation of 8 substantive aspect Non pecuniary damage award information Press Release Related E associated with a KH v THE UNITED KINGDOM document only in English Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fourth Section 27 08 2011 t 1458 Case Details Legal Summary Press Release Related 6 CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY 1473709 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Second qu 12 07 2011 Preliminary objection dismissed non exhaustion of domestic remedies Violation of 8 No violation of Art 8 Remainder in more Case Details Legal Summary Language Versions Press Release Related Language versions including translations into non official languages 30 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights 1 Print Click on the rt button to print the entire list of results 2 Export Click on the 8 2 button to export at least 500 results by default into an Excel document You will be able to filter your results using the Excel functions 3 RSS Click on the 5 button to create
20. All judgments decisions and advisory opinions not included in the Case Reports which make a significant contribution to the development clarification or modification of the Court s case law either generally or in relation to a particular State 11 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights 2 Medium importance Other judgments decisions and advisory opinions which while not making a significant contribution to the case law nevertheless go beyond merely applying existing case law 3 Low importance Judgments decisions and advisory opinions of little legal interest namely judgments and decisions that simply apply existing case law friendly settlements and strikeouts unless raising a particular point of interest This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents in each importance level IMPORTANCE 3 20882 2 8356 1 4153 Case Reports 1572 When you click the importance level filter is displayed by category in descending order of importance You can sort the Importance filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order What do we mean by texts analysed by importance level Owing to the large number of cases concerned from 2007 onwards only limited analytical information is available in respect of judgments and decisions of lesser interest in terms of the Cour
21. Costs and expenses partial Filters can be easily added or removed by clicking on the button in the criteria bar the button in the filter on the left hand side of the screen The filters are as follows Language Importance State Article Non violation and Violation The number of documents for each filter is indicated in brackets 1 Language Use the Language filter to search by document language Please note The Court is only responsible for French and English texts translated by the Registry It accepts no responsibility for the quality or content of translations into non official languages and their appearance in HUDOC does not amount to an endorsement by the Court This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents in each language When you click on More a box will show you the complete list of languages available in alphabetical order with the number of documents in brackets 10 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights To sort your results language Azerbaidjani 34 Bosnian 43 Bulgarian 37 English 14929 Tick the box to select a language Mistonian 45 See the number of documents by language inside the brackets bracketsImportance level You Georgian 77 German 15 Icelandic 5 kalian 128 Latvian 17 To close the Language box Lithuanian 15 Polish 209
22. E OF LUTSENKO v UKRAINE E 6492 11 Available only in English Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fifth Section 03 07 2012 c gt in Council of Europe European Court of Human Rights Case Law Analysis Privacy Help Back to top HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Document collection You can narrow your search by document collection On the left hand side of the screen you DOCUMENT COLLECTIONS can choose which case law collections Case Law 31323 you want to search in El Iv Judgments 31323 Iv Grand Chamber 848 I Chamber 30475 Please note that the default collection Committee 0 to search is JUDGMENTS of the Grand Decisions 0 Chamber and Chamber To search in Admissibility 0 other collections such as DECISIONS Screening 0 tick the appropriate box Communicated Cazes 0 Legal Summaries 0 Advisory Opinions 0 Reports 0 Ell Resolutions 0 Number of documents Execution 0 in brackets Merits 0 The case law of the Convention institutions has been split into separate document collections which can be searched either individually or together Judgments Grand Chamber Chamber and Committee Admissibility and Screening Panel Decisions Communicated Cases Advisory Opinions Reports and Resolutions of the Committee of Ministers Legal Summaries are extracted from the Court s Case l
23. Forthcoming judgments engine is designed above all to help fine tune Statistics 26 06 2012 searches of the 30 000 documents currently Th Comit dll be deliverina fs Grand stored in the database It was entirely funded T Factsheets gun Dir ER HE ae by voluntary contributions from the Bl country profiles G nes v Turkey on 29 June 2012 The case oo ae ES concerns compliance with the 6 month time ids Publications limit admissibility criterion All press releases issued by the Registry since 1 January 1999 are available in the HUDOC database They include summaries of judgments and decisions delivered by the Court and information about pending cases and about the Court s activities in general Press releases are always available in both English and French and are in HTML Word and or PDF format Press releases on the Court s judgments are published at 10 a m on Tuesdays and Thursdays when judgments are delivered Forthcoming press releases are announced a week in advance with a short summary of the cases concerned Hearings are announced during the preceding month 44 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights IX The toolbar The toolbar is on the main page f EX in Council of Europe European Court af Human Rights Case Law Analysis Privacy Help Back to top It is composed of ap tweet the HUDOC Search Page link Twitter f To publish the HUDOC Sear
24. Press Releases French press releases Arret de chambre Sneersone et Kampanella c Italie 12 07 11 in th e case Annonce arr ts 12 07 11 When you click on the Press Release link a new window will open showing you the Press Release view Chamber judgment Szuluk v the United Kingdom 02 06 09 Press Release Chamber Judgments 02 06 2009 Document URL http hudocbeta sites eng pages search aspx i 2752478 amp c eng View Case Details Translation Related View Psi EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COUR EUROPEENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME 439 02 06 2009 Press release issued by the Registrar CHAMBER JUDGMENT Press Release SZULUK v THE UNITED KINGDOM The European Court of Human Rights has today notified in writing its Chamber judgment 1 in the case of Szuluk v the United Kingdom application no 36936 05 concerning the monitoring by prison authorities of medical correspondence between the applicant a convicted prisoner and his external specialist doctor The Court held unanimously that there had been a violation of Article 8 right to respect for private and family life and for correspondence of the European Convention on Human Rights Under Article 41 just satisfaction of the Convention the Court awarded the applicant 1 000 euros EUR for non pecuniary damage and EUR 6 000 for costs and expenses The judgment is available only in English 1 Principal facts 41 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Cour
25. TION 8 62 x 8 14 14 15 8 9 8 10 8 1 8 13 7 3 5 KEYWORDS a Art 8 Right to respect for private and family life 62 Art 8 1 Respect for family 62 x Art 8 2 Necessary a democratic society 35 Art 8 2 Interference 30 65 results are found 29 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights A Viewing search results To export the Number of To print the results list in To create an RSS feed results list Excel format for the search criteria Sort by CRITERIA CLEAR ALL Document Collection ld Committee Decisiong x Importance Level 1 x Mon violation 8 x results 55 Results FoudTid Keywo Click on the x to H v THE NETHERLANDS clear the selected Court Grand Chamber 03 0472U criteria Right to respect for private and family life To clear all CASE criteria 42857 05 violation of Article sse Details Legal Summary Language Versions Fress Release CASE OF AHRENS v GERMANY 45071 09 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fifth Section 22 03 2012 Remainder inadmissible No violation of Art 8 No tion of Art 14 2 Case Details Language Versions Press Relesse RY Click on case title to see the document in Web HTML format document 6 CASE OF GAS AND DUBOIS v FRAN 25951 07 Available only in French Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fifth Section
26. To view the applicability data associated with a case from the HUDOC case law collection open the Case Details page for more information see Viewing the Case Details below page 33 22 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights G Conclusion A number of documents in the HUDOC collection contain a brief summary of the outcome of the case for example whether there was a violation of the Convention and whether any award was made in respect of damage Below are some examples of conclusions included on the Portal Violation of Article 6 1 Pecuniary damage award No violation of Article 14 8 Struck out of the list Use the Conclusion field to search according to the outcome of a case Examples Violation No violation Admissible Inadmissible Remainder inadmissible To help you in your search the lists below list all the possible types of conclusions 1 Conclusions of Judgments Preliminary objections Preliminary objection allowed x Preliminary objections allowed x x Preliminary objection partially allowed Preliminary objections partially allowed Preliminary objection dismissed x Preliminary objections dismissed x x x Preliminary objection partially dismissed x Preliminary objections partially dismissed x x x Preliminary objection joined to merits x Preliminary objections joined to merits x x Preliminary objection joined to merits and dismissed x Preliminary objec
27. aanreeeesmnupera E 18 2 COUR Se ee sarees eaeademesaan 19 3 Use E aE E douse venneusaaianisueee 19 4 OOM aun issus RUEREROEPERVSUFPITNEERUITENURISUDIERUPIRII ERU IMRREREEIQEIDEPPRERM 19 5 UP A RN PRENDI 20 VI Advanced Search ziisvesuskaubkswREREFREEKFEEEENEZERREIEEFEREEEENEFNEEEFEREREKKNEKREI RENE REIR 20 A B QOEM TH A 21 B 21 C Application NUMIDET ee ee eU rr o REA EV ad 22 D Strasbourg Case laW ssssssssssssesssssnsnsussssnenrsssnnnsersnsnsennssennnsessnsnsnesrenenense 22 RSS Or ds UNTER 22 F nissecler M 22 G COMMIS 23 1 Conclusions Of scar 23 2 Conclusions DECISIONS 1131522 92 24 34 Conclusions of Communicated Cases 25 4 Conclusions of Interim 25 5 Conclusions of Final CoU RR ia 25 Resolution 25 ED E MC
28. amage finding of violation sufficient Pecuniary and non pecuniary damage finding of violation sufficient Respondent State to take individual measures Respondent State to take measures of a general character Interpretation Non pecuniary damage claim dismissed Non pecuniary damage award Non pecuniary damage finding of violation sufficient Non pecuniary damage reserved Reopening of case Restitution of the disputed property or financial award Just satisfaction partially reserved Just satisfaction dismissed out of time Just satisfaction reserved 2 Conclusions of Decisions Struck out of the list Restored to the list Admissible Inadmissible Partly inadmissible Partly admissible Partly inadmissible Partly struck out of the list Partly inadmissible Partly struck out of the list Partly admissible Partly admissible Partly inadmissible Partly struck out of the list Preliminary objections joined to merits Admissible Preliminary objections joined to merits Partly admissible Partly inadmissible Restored to the list Adjournment of the examination of the application Non pecuniary damage award 24 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights 3 Conclusions of Communicated Cases Communicated 4 Conclusions of Interim Resolutions Respondent State urged to take individual measures Respondent State urged to take measures of a general character Respondent State urged to pay just satisfa
29. ated French Documents Chamber Judgments AFFAIRE SNEERSONE ET KAMPANELLA c Legal Summaries 4 French legal summaries Sneersone and c Italie for the case Press Releases Arret de chambre Sneersone et c Italie 12 07 11 Annonce arr ts 12 07 11 When you click on the Legal Summary link a new window will open showing you the Legal Summary view Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 14737 09 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 002 436 View Case Details Language Versions Related EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COUR EUROP ENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME Information Note on the Court s case law No 143 July 2011 Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 14737109 Judgment 12 7 2011 Section II Lega Summa ry Article 8 Article 8 1 Respect for family life Order for return of minor child who had been living with mother in Latvia to father in Italy without due consideration of child s best interests violation Facts The second applicant whose mother the first applicant is Latvian and father Italian was born in Italy in 2002 A year later his parents separated and he has lived with his mother ever since The mother was granted custody by an Italian court in September 2004 She left Italy for Latvia in April 2006 taking the second applicant with her Subsequently the Italian courts granted the father sole custody In 2007 the Latvian courts dec
30. aw Information Note The Registry summarises cases which it considers to be of particular interest These summaries are not binding on the Court Each summary is linked to the corresponding Communicated Case Decision or Judgment It is classified by the Convention Article s to which the case relates and by keywords and comprises a descriptive headnote a concise presentation of the facts and a presentation of the law with the emphasis on points of legal interest New documents are added regularly to the Portal At present the availability of documents on the Portal is as follows Court Judgments Admissibility decisions November 1998 Court Judgments Screening Panel decisions 1959 October 1998 Court Communicated Cases 12 12 2011 gt Commission Admissibility decisions 1986 Commission Admissibility decisions 1955 1986 some published decisions Commission 196035 Reports public only 1963 gt Committee of Ministers Resolutions execution 19729 Committee of Ministers Resolutions merits From 1959 to July 2004 Please note that the default collection to search is JUDGMENTS of the Grand Chamber and Chamber To search in other collections such as DECISIONS tick the appropriate box The number of documents in each collection is indicated in brackets HUDOC Manual For example see screenshot above Chamber 30475 IV Simple search Use this field to perform a searc
31. below page 33 N Search in document sections The Advanced Search screen also contains a Search in Document Sections field Click on the button to expand the field search in Document Sections Procedure For these reasons The Facts Separate Opinion s Complaints Appendix The Law You can refine your text search by document section broken down as follows Procedure The Facts Complaints Law these reasons Separate Opinion s and Appendix You can carry out a multiple zone search within a document Entering terms in the Document Sections boxes carries out a search for a particular item in the specific zone of the document whether it be a single word a phrase a sentence etc You can use all the options available to carry out more complex searches see the Search Syntax section above page 5 27 HUDOC BURO EEE VII How to sort your results You can choose how you want the database to sort your results NB the default sort is by RELEVANCE Click on the arrow next to the Sort by box on the right of the screen to select an item from the drop down menu Sort by Relevance Relevance when searching for particular term in the text Date Newest this option will give the document with the most occurrences Date Oldest of this term first Case Title 4 2 Date Newest first chronological order Date Oldest first reverse chronological order Ti
32. ber LANGUAGE IMPORTANCE an d C h am be r DCUM sew AFFAIRE GOLOVAN c UKRAINE French 14950 2 6358 S judgments by E ove 41716 06 Available only in English Arr t au principal et satisfaction Equitable Cour Cinquieme Se Russian 436 1 4154 l defau It Polish 209 Case Reports Exception pr liminaire jointe au fond et rejet e Article 35 1 Epuisement des voies de recours internes Part More 1573 Case Details Press Release Related More STATE ARTICLE AFFAIRE ASSOCIATION LES TEMOINS DE JEHOVAH c FRANCE Turkey 5614 6 17559 8916 05 Available only in French Arr t satisfaction quitable Cour Cinqui me Section 05 07 2012 italy 4489 6 1 16670 Dommage mat riel r paration Pr judice moral demande rejet e Russia 2665 41 16330 Case Details Legal Summary Press Release Related Poland 2071 29 5308 More More 2 new AFFAIRE GLOBA c UKRAINE NON VIOLATION VIOLATION 15729 07 Available only in English Arr t au principal et satisfaction quitable Cour Cinqui me Section 05 07 2012 6 1631 6 13688 aii a 2 cn din Aaah Ara E ankn ciiis Arii d 51a radionnnahin Violation de l article 6 Droit a un proces equitable Article 6 Procedure civile Article 6 1 Delai raisonnable 6 1 1364 6 1 12868 3 835 5 2673 Lease Details ress Release telatecd 5 679 13 2506 TM More sew CAS
33. ce OR violence Not any of these words is NOT AND NOT search If you enter police violence you will search for NOT police AND NOT violence HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights The Boolean search field allows you to manually enter Boolean terms if you are more comfortable with that Please refer to the ECHR Portal Boolean Searching Syntax table above page 5 C Word suggestions If you make a mistake in the spelling of a word the search will not return any results However it will suggest that you make sure all words are spelled correctly try different search terms or try more general search terms If there is one it will also suggest a word You can click on the suggestion in blue and search for it Example Violance Results Found Frit Export RSS Wrong spelling of the word violence CRITERIA CLEAR ALL sort Relevance x Document type excluding Committee x Text search violance You typed violance did you mean violence 7 The search did not return any results Suggestion of the word violence Suggestions Make sure all words are spelled correctly Try different search terms Try more general search terms HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights V Narrowing your search A Filters The filter panel on the left FILTERS hand side of the screen helps LANGUAGE IMPORTANCE yOu to NAON YOU SEANN French 1269 3 1448 English 1236
34. ch Page link on your Facebook wall cf To go the YouTube page of the European Court of Human Rights WWW youtube com user EuropeanCourt To access the HUDOC Judgments and Decisions RSS feeds nM To share the HUDOC Search Page link on http www linkedin com Council af Europe A To access the Council of Europe website http www coe int European Court af Human Rights 4 To access the European Court of Human Rights website http www echr coe int ECHR Homepage_EN To access the Case Law Information Notes and Index To read the Privacy Statement To be directed to the Help page see below Back to top BBB go to the top of the page A Help This page consists of 40 An explanation of the HUDOC database 40 A link to the User Manual Links to Video tutorials 45 HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Francais HUDOC Database The HUDOC database provides access to the case law of the European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber Chamber and Committee judgments decisions communicated cases advisory opinions and legal summaries from the Case Law Information Note the European Commission of Human Rights decisions and reports and the Committee of Ministers resolutions Click here to access the HUDOC database On line HUDOC manual will be available in the coming weeks Video tutorials
35. ctions award 5 Conclusions of Final Resolutions Information given by the government concerning measures taken to prevent new violations Payment of the sums provided for in the judgment Information given by the government concerning measures taken to prevent new violations Payment of the sums provided for in the friendly settlement Information given by the government concerning measures taken for the execution of the undertakings attached to the solution of the case Payment of the sums provided for in the friendly settlement TIP To view the conclusions in a case from the HUDOC case law collection open the Case Details page for more information see Viewing the Case Details below page 33 H Resolution Number Use the Resolution Number field to search for Committee of Ministers Resolutions pertaining to a case by typing all or part of the Resolution number in the box Example 36022 97 I Date First field Second field Date to daifhmrysy Separate Opinion Domestic Law Tu We Ih Fr Sa Su International amp Other Relevant Material 1 2 E 4 5 keyword i4 15 16 17 18 19 20 e 23 23 234 25 26 N Reasons fire PEST EET Dates must always be entered using the format DD MM YYYY You can use the automatic calendar 25 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Dates are inclusive For example searching from 01 01 1996 to 31 12 1996 will return all 1996 documents Searching f
36. e Organisations filter is displayed in alphabetical order You can sort the Organisation filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order VI Advanced Search Advanced Search Click on to open the Advanced Search screen The Advanced Search screen is composed of different search fields 4ADY ANCED SEARCH Text Conclusion Resolution Number Case Title Place your mouse on Date daimmAryyy to ddimmAnyy Yum for a definition of Application Number Brem d 2 ves the search field strasbourg Case Layy e Domestic Lawy Click here to display Rules of Court International Law and the Keywords list Applicability 0 Other Relevant Material Keywords Search in Document Sections Click here to perform the search You can find a definition of each field by placing your mouse over the question mark For example Use the Conclusion field to search according to the outcome of a case Examples Violation No violation Admissible Inadmissible Remainder inadmissible Advanced Search Conclusion Field 2312 Ll ume mm FPE AA 20 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights You can do a combined search of two or more search fields For example ADYANCED SEARCH Text prison Conclusion Resolution Number Title Date
37. e Registry since 31 December 1998 are available in the HUDOC database They are always available in both English and French Each case of particular interest judgments admissibility and inadmissibility decisions and communicated cases is summarised with a concise presentation of the facts and a presentation of the law with the emphasis on points of legal interest The summary has a descriptive headnote and provides a classification by Articles and keywords All summaries are included in the monthly Case law Information Note and the annual Index available for free in PDF format by clicking on this link http www echr coe int ECHR EN Header Case Law Case law analysis Information notes Or by clicking on the links on the Court s homepage 38 HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights SEARCH HUDOC CASE LAW EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN BRIGHTS COUR EUROPEENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME Fran ais Site 2 Contact Disclaimer Privacy Link to the Case Law Information Notes News The Court E Basic Texts Grand Chamber judgments Case Law Decisions and judgments Reports Case law analysis Information notes Pending Cases Useful links Admissibility quide E followed its finding Research reports hunting legislation Applicants Factsheets German versio Handbook on non discrimination A Hearing of 30 Other publications El Multimed
38. e application number of the case Type any part of the application number in the box and click on the number you are looking for from the list of suggestions Example 3394 03 D Strasbourg Case law Use the Strasbourg Case law field to search for judgments and decisions Importance Case Reports 1 and 2 in which a particular Court or Commission case has been cited Example typing Hatton 36022 97 in this field will return all cases in which the Hatton v United Kingdom judgment was cited TIP To view the Strasbourg case law associated with a case from the HUDOC case law collection open the Case Details page for more information see Viewing the Case Details below page 33 E Rules of Court Use the Rules of Court field to search for cases Importance Case Reports 1 and 2 containing references to the Court s procedural rules Only the Rule number should be entered in the field Examples 39 53 4 TIP To view the Rules of Court associated with a case from the HUDOC case law collection open the Case Details page for more information see Viewing the Case Details below page 33 F Applicability Use the Applicability field to search for cases Importance Case Reports 1 and 2 in which the question of the applicability of a particular provision of the Convention or Protocols has been raised Examples Art 8 applicable Art 8 inapplicable P1 1 applicable P1 1 inapplicable Art 6 discussed TIP
39. ecisions communicated cases reports resolutions Legal summaries Press releases F Viewing the Legal Summaries Legal Summaries can be found under Document Collections DOCUMENT COLLECTIONS El 4 Case Law 1937 Judgments 0 Grand Chamber 0 Chamber 0 Committee 0 Ell Decisions 0 Admissibility 0 Screening Panel 0 Communicated Cazes 0 i Legal Summaries 1937 Legal Summaries Advisory Opinions 0 Reports 0 Resolutions 0 Execution 0 Merits 0 In the results list CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY 14737 08 Judgment Meritt and Just Satisfaction Court Second Section 12 07 2011 Preliminary objection dismissed non exhaustion of domestic remedies Violation of amp No violation of Art amp Details Legs Summary Language Versions Fress Release Related Legal Summary and by clicking on Related 36 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY 1473709 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Second Section 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 001 105624 Related View Case Details Language Versions Related Related English Documents Legal Summaries English legal summaries for the case Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy Press Releases Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 12 07 11 Announce judgments 12 07 11 Rel
40. ecution 0 Merits 0 Press Collection Link to the Press Collection This takes you to a special database for press releases Francais Advanced Search HUDOC European Court of Human Rights Press Releases NARROW YOUR SEARCH 8650 Results Found Print Export RSS Sort By Date newest FILTERS LANGUAGE STATE Sort Date newest x English 4575 Turkey 1804 French 4075 Ukraine 788 Renvoi devant la Grande Chambre 04 06 2012 More Russia 785 Communiqu de presse Renvois devant la grande chambre Published On 27 06 2012 Slovakia 712 Details Related More DOCUMENT TYPE w Referral to the Grand Chamber April 2012 Chamber Judgments 5121 Press Release Referrals to Grand Chamber Published On 27 06 2012 General 893 Details Related Hearings 879 Forthcoming Judgments 762 Grand Chamber Judgments 437 Arr t de Grande Chambre Herrmann c Allemagne 26 06 2012 Admissibility Decisions 291 Forthcoming Hearings 148 Referrals to Grand Chamber 112 Referrals 7 Communiqu de presse Arr ts de grande chambre Published On 26 06 2012 Details Related Annonce d arr ts de chambre 3 5 07 12 More Communiqu de presse Prochains arr ts Published On 26 06 2012 DATE Details Related Last Week 30 Last Month Grand Chamber judgment Herrmann v Germany German version 26 06 2012 110 Press Release Grand Chamber Judgments Published On 26
41. elevision Police NOT prison violence NEAR damage hot water NEAR prison HUDOC Manual Finds documents in which the specified terms Precedence although not necessarily together must appear in the specified order word word Replaces any number of missing letters character or ab wildcard Single character Replaces any single letter a b wildcard For example Combinations of the above search criteria are also possible B Simple Boolean Search screen HUDOC European Court of Human Rights radio television hearing conviction violat violation violate violates violated violator violating etc violate violated violates You can also open the Simple Boolean Search screen by clicking on the arrow The Exact Phrase a All of these Any of these al Not any of these Boolean Search r Click on Clear to clear your query The screen offers you five possibilities This exact word or phrase is a phrase search Open the simple Boolean search screen by clicking on the arrow The simple Boolean search screen more If you enter Court of Cassation the system will search for Court of Cassation All of these words is an AND search If you enter police violence the system will search for police AND violence Any of these words is OR search If you enter police violence the system will search for poli
42. h in one or more collections SEARCH HUDOC European Court of Human Rights You can perform a search by entering a single word a phrase a group of words a case title an application number a State a Boolean phrase etc Click on to perform the search A Search syntax To assist you in carrying out searches the table below details the many different types of search syntax that the Portal understands and provides practical examples of their USE Search parameter Word Phrase sentence paragraph AND OR NOT Proximity ECHR Portal Boolean Searching Syntax Meaning A sequence of one or more adjacent letters or numbers Groups together words in the order you wish to find them phrase searching word word Finds documents containing both terms in any order word AND word or phrase AND word or phrase AND phrase etc Finds documents containing either of the two terms word OR word or phrase OR word or phrase OR phrase Finds documents that do not contain the specified term word NOT word or phrase NOT phrase Finds documents in which the specified terms are near each other word NEAR word or phrase NEAR word or phrase NEAR phrase Examples i e what to type in the Text field Burglary Constitution prison sentence Court of Cassation Law no 65 543 police AND violence hot water AND prison violence OR cruelty police OR army hot water OR prison NOT t
43. ia Suus em The Court has found a violation of the Convention in the case of Library Kuric and Others v Slovenia concerning the rights of the erased that is people wha were unable to acquire or keep the nationality of the new Slovenian State created in 1981 Having e Recent press applied the pilot judgment procedure the Court indicated that the Government should within releases one year set up an ad hoc domestic compensation scheme for the erased In the interim it would adjourn its examination of all similar applications Calendar of ic 06 07 2011 Link to the Case Law Information Notes 5 New technologies imber 1 Tone Delon New HUDOC database before the Grand 23 06 2012 26 06 2012 Chamber The Court has accepted the referral to the A new version of Grand Chamber of the case X v Latvia 3 Hudac the ruri Notes Press Release HUDOC Court s case law 5 Eurepean Court of Human Rights database is now r FAQ on line This new more intuitive search Forthcoming judgments engine is designed above all to help fine tune Statistics 26 06 2012 searches of the 90 000 documents currently stored in the database It was entirely funded by voluntary contributions from the Governments of Cyprus Denmark Germany The Court will be delivering its Grand SEES UES Chamber judgment in the case of Sabri Ea Country profiles G ne v Turkey on 29 June 2012 The case and Mea concer
44. ided on the basis of a psychologist s report that the boy s return to Italy would not be in his best interests and might even provoke neurotic problems and illnesses The Italian courts subsequently ordered the child s return to Italy on the basis of European Council Regulation No 2201 2003 concerning jurisdiction in matters of parental responsibility the Regulation Latvia brought an action against Italy before the 37 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Click on Case Details for information concerning the legal summary such as title Articles and keywords Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 14737 09 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 002 436 View Case Details Language Versions Related Terms Case Details Title Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy App No s 14737 09 Importance Level 1 Respondent State s Italy Conclusion s Preliminary objection dismissed non exhaustion of domestic remedies Violation of Art 8 No violation of Art 8 Remainder inadmissible Non pecuniary damage award 8 8 1 8 2 35 35 1 41 Keywords Art 35 Admissibility criteria Art 35 1 Exhaustion of domestic remedies Art 8 Right to respect for private and family life Art 8 1 Respect for family life Art 8 2 Interference Art 8 2 Necessary in a democratic society Margin of appreciation Art 41 Just satisfaction general All legal summaries issued by th
45. lect an Article You can select one or 5 885 more Articles 5 1 289 5 1 a 4 5 1 c 29 5 1 19 5 2 37 5 4 105 51 2 6 Z 5 5 21 1 confirm the selection of Article s You can sort the Non violation filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order bal 6 Violation Use the Violation filter to search for judgments Grand Chamber Chamber and Committee in which the Court found a violation of the Convention or Protocol Article s indicated This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents containing a finding of a violation of the Article s in question 14 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Examples select 8 to find cases in which there was a finding of a violation of Article 8 of the Convention Select P1 3 to find cases in which there was a finding of a violation of Article 3 of Protocol No 1 When you click on More the list of violations is displayed in the order of appearance of the Articles of the Convention and additional Protocols You can sort the Violation filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order B Keywords You can narrow your search using the keywords Use the Keywords filter to search for documen
46. me 1678 Section 2937 More Court Fourth ORGANISATION European Court of Human Rights 8572 European Central Bank 5547 European Commission 2443 Council af Europe 1621 More section 2831 You can further narrow your search by using More Filters These additional filters are Date Courts Judges Originating Body and Organisations The number of documents for each filter is indicated in brackets These filters are displayed by default in descending order of the number of documents 1 Date Use the Date filter to search by period Examples Last Week Last 5 Years etc This filter is displayed in ascending order of the number of documents by period 18 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights 2 Courts Use the Courts filter to search by international courts and national courts of the 47 Council of Europe member States mentioned in the texts Examples Cour de cassation Supreme Court etc This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents by court When you click on More the courts are displayed in alphabetical order You can sort the Courts filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order 3 Judges Use the Judges filter to search for cases where a particular judge from the Court or a member of the Commission is mentioned in
47. n 437 Art 12 Right to marry 58 rt 13 Right to an effective remedy 3821 Art 14 Prohibition of discrimination 1572 Art 15 Derogation in time of emergency 53 Art 15 Restrictions on political activity of aliens general 5 Art 17 Prohibition of abuse of rights 141 Art 18 Limitation on use of restrictions on rights 197 Art 19 Establishment of the Court 6 Art 33 Inter State cases general 10 Art 34 Individual applications 1548 Art 35 Admissibility criteria 4001 Art 37 Striking out applications 2088 Art 38 Examination of the case and friendly settlement proceedings 11458 Art 39 Finding fart 231 4 TO confirm the he Link to the list selection of of keywords by keywords Keywords by Article Article Keyword search field 7e You can enter keyword in the search field and click on the button The keyword will be highlighted in red and the number of results found will be displayed For example torture torture 2 results found Art 1 Obligatio Searching for torture Art 2 Right to life Art 3 Prohibition of torture 21 Art 3 Degrading punishments Art 3 Degrading treatment 11 Art 3 Effective investigation D Art 3 Expulsion Art 3 Extradition 0 Art 3 Inhuman pu
48. n click on the E icon to contract a keyword and hide any child keywords For example in the case of Article 10 Parent keyword Art 10 Freedom of expression Generali 1583 Art 10 1 Freedom of expression 1133 Art 10 1 Freedom to hold opinions 14 Art 10 1 Freedom to impart ideas 143 Art 10 1 Freedom to impart information 104 Art 10 1 Freedom to ideas 2 Art 10 1 Freedom to receive information 34 Art 10 1 Interference 18 Art 10 1 Licensing of broadcasting enterprises 21 Art 10 1 Public authority 11 Art 10 1 Regardless of frontiers 0 Art 10 2 Duties and responsibilities 57 Art 10 2 Interference 545 Art 10 2 Necessary a democratic society 962 E Art 10 2 Prescribed by law 445 A list of keywords has been assigned to each Article of the European Convention on Human Rights and its Protocols The list will help you use the keywords effectively It Supplements the list available via the Keywords lookup on the HUDOC search portal which is arranged in alphabetical order http www echr coe int ECHR EN HUDOC keywords HUDOC European Court of Human Rights Francais List of Keywords Article by Article The legal issues dealt with in each case are summarized in a list of Keywords chosen from a thesaurus of terms taken in most cases directly from the text of the European Conventio
49. n on Human Rights and additional Protocols Searching with these keywords will enable you to find group of documents with similar legal content The list below supplements the list available via the Keywords tab on the Hudoc search portal European Convention on Human Rights Article 1 Article 16 Article 53 former Article 60 Article 2 Article 17 Article 54 former Article 61 Article 3 Article 18 Article 55 former Article 62 Article 4 Article 19 Article 56 former Article 63 Article 5 Article 33 former Article 24 Article 57 former Article 64 Article 6 Article 34 former Article 25 Article 58 former Article 65 Article 7 Article 35 Article 59 former Article 66 Article 8 Article 37 former Article 30 Former Article 25 Article 8 Article 38 former Article 28 Former Article 32 Article 10 Article 39 Former Article 44 Article 11 Article 41 former Article 501 Former Article 45 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights C More filters MORE FILTERS DATE COURTS Last Week 44 Supreme Court Last Month 3053 184 Cour de Last 6 Months cassation 976 3010 Last Year Constitutional 1734 Court 1710 Last 5 Years Court of 13635 Cassation Last 10 Years 1259 24305 More JUDGES ORIGINATING BODY Nicolas Bratza o 3278 Court Second Christos Section 3818 Rozakis 3048 Court First Francoise section 3548 Tulkens 1838 Cour Peer Lorenzen Deuxi
50. nce in the Convention and additional Protocols 1 103 Number of documents by Article 2 1152 2 1 877 2 2 169 Tick the box to select an Article i You can select one or more Articles 87 4 2 40 5 3454 5 1 1519 5 1 a 127 5 1 b 90 5 1 c 385 5 1 e 150 5 1 177 4 E m 5 2 156 z EMEN confirm the selection of Article s You can sort the Article filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order 13 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights 5 Non violation Use the Non violation filter to search for judgments Grand Chamber Chamber and Committee in which the Court found no violation of the Convention or Protocol Article s indicated This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents containing a finding of no violation of the Article s in question Examples select 8 to find cases in which there was a finding of no violation of Article 8 of the Convention Select P1 3 to find cases in which there was a finding of no violation of Article 3 of Protocol No 1 When you click on More the non violation filter is displayed in the order of appearance of the Articles of the Convention and additional Protocols 2 321 Number of documents by Article 2 1 12 3 821 SEES DM Tick the box to se
51. nishment 2 Art 3 Inhuman treatment 122 3 Positive obligghetts Art 3 Torture 0 Keywords related to torture in red Tick the box 38H81111111111111 P 1 4 Prohibition af slavery and forced labour 0 Art 5 Right to liberty and security 31 Art 6 Right to a fair trial 414 Art 7 Mo punishment without law 34 Art 8 Right to respect for private and family life 50 Art 9 Freedom of thought conscience and religion 60 Art 10 Freedom of expression Generali 1133 Art 11 Freedom of assembly and association 79 Art 12 Right to marry 0 Art 13 Right to an effective remedy 87 Art 14 Prohibition of discrimination 147 Art 15 Deragation in time of emergency 2 Art 16 Restrictions on political activity of aliens general 5 EAr ahime mt rine PHA HEA Hee eee ee EH x CLOSE Keywords by Article You can select one or more keywords by the box to the left of the keyword Once you have made your selection click on the button to confirm TIP Other information concerning keywords can be found in the Keywords section under Advanced Search page 25 16 HUDOC European Court of Human Rights HUDOC Manual Each keyword in the hierarchy can contain child keywords which are directly related to the parent keyword By clicking the icon next to a keyword you can view any child keywords You ca
52. not responsible for the content of external websites and the inclusion of a link in the list below does not constitute any endorsement of the site or the materials contained on it Links are listed by country and if there is more than one link for a country by alphabetical order Further links will be added from time to time If you have a suggestion for a new site to be included in the list or are a Web or other publishers interested in having translations integrated into the HUDOC database or if you wish to contact us to object to a link to your site please let us know using this form Select the option Send any comments concerning HUDOC Publishers organisations and governments who would like to submit non official translations for inclusion in the Court s database HUDOC are invited to follow this procedure SB The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia http www w pravda gov mk tekstovi3 asp langzmak amp id presudi2008 Albania http www magjistratura edu al fq in fo amp metod sh faqkat amp katID id_vendime Andorra http www w bopa ad bopa nsf c56341fced070c89c12566c700571ddd 2fef4f7d3438608dc12575a70020ce05 O0penDocument amp Highlight 2 38196962F05 http www w bopa ad bopa nsf c56341fced070c89c12566c700571ddd 038b72a6c3750af7c12575e000206fe7 OpenDocument Armenia http www justice am Links to third party Internet sites 2 uw Austria http www w menschenrechte ac at newsletter menschenrechte archiv html
53. ns compliance with the 6 month time a F Publications limit admissibility criterion HUDOC 39 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights You can also access this page by clicking on the link at the end of the legal summary Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 14737 09 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 002 436 View Case Details Language Versions Related cid Terms addressed by the Italian courts The Italian courts did not refer to the two psychologists reports that had been drawn up in Latvia or to the potential dangers to the boy s psychological health the reports identified No effort was made by the Italian authorities to inspect the accommodation proposed by the father to establish its suitability as a home for a young child The Court was thus unpersuaded that the Italian courts had sufficiently appreciated the seriousness of the difficulties the child was likely to encounter in Italy Nor could the safeguards of the child s well being accepted by the Italian courts be regarded as adequate allowing the first applicant to stay with the child for fifteen to thirty days during the first year and then for one summer month every other year was a manifestly inappropriate response to the psychological trauma that would inevitably follow a sudden and irreversible severance of the close ties between mother and child the provision of facilities such as a kindergarten
54. rom 01 09 1994 to 30 09 1994 will return all documents from September 1994 If you put a date in the first field it means you want to start your search at that date If you only put a date in the second field it means you want to stop your search at that date and find all documents before that date J Separate Opinion s Use the Separate Opinion s field to find judgments in which one or more judges have issued or have not issued a separate opinion concurring partly concurring partly dissenting or dissenting K Domestic Law Use the Domestic Law field to search for cases Importance Case Reports 1 and 2 in which a specific domestic legal provision has been cited Example Trade Union and Labour Relations Act 1974 TIP To view the domestic law associated with a case from the HUDOC case law collection open the Case Details page for more information see Viewing the Case Details below page 33 L International Law amp Other Relevant Material Use the International Law amp Other Relevant Material field to search for cases Importance Case Reports 1 and 2 in which a specific international or non national text has been cited Examples Articles 12 and 14 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities TIP To view the international law and other relevant material associated with a case from the HUDOC case law collection open the Case Details page for more information see Viewing
55. rt of Human Rights Francais Advanced Search NARROW YOUR SEARCH 31394 Results Found Print EJ Export BY RSS Sort by Relevance DOCUMENT COLLECTIONS E El V Case Law 31394 CRITERIA ans eee Document Collection Id Committee Decisions EM Judgments 31394 Iv Grand Chamber 857 pew CASE OF ASSOCIATION LES TEMOINS DE JEHOVAH v FRANCE I n 8916 05 Available only in French Judgment Just Satisfaction Court Fifth Section 05 07 2012 0 a Pecuniary damage award Non pecuniary damage claim dismissed Decisions 0 E Admissibility 0 Case Details Legal Summary Press Release Related Screening Panel 0 new CASE OF GOLOVAN v UKRAINE Legal Summaries 0 41716 06 Available only in English Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fifth Section 05 07 2012 Advisory Opinions 0 Preliminary objection joined to merits and dismissed Article 35 1 Exhaustion of domestic remedies Remainder inadmissible more Reports 0 Case Details Press Release Related Resolutions 0 Execution 0 apum I sex CASE OF GLOBA v UKRAINE 1572907 Available only in English Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Fifth Section 05 07 2012 Press Collection mE j li Violation of Article 6 Right to a fair trial Article 6 Civil proceedings Article 6 1 Reasonable time HLT Case Details Press Release Related La st G ra nd Cha m
56. t of Human Rights Some press releases are available in PDF format only Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 12 07 11 Press Release Chamber Judgments 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 003 3604959 4084321 View Case Details Language Versions Related EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COUR EUROP ENNE DES DROITS DE L HOMME This document is available only in PDF format Click here to download it Ce document n est disponible qu en format PDF Cliquez ici pour le t l charger Click on Case Details for information concerning the press release such as document type and title Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 12 07 11 Press Release Chamber Judgments 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 003 3604959 4084321 View Case Details Language Versions Related Case Details Document Type Press Release Chamber Judgments Title Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 12 07 11 You can also access the complete press release collection by clicking on the Press Collection link 42 HUDOC European Court of Human Rights HUDOC Manual DOCUMENT COLLECTIONS A OM Case Law 31211 EM Judgments 21211 Grand Chamber 848 Iv Chamber 30463 Committee 0 Decisions 0 Admissibility 0 screening 0 Communicated Cases 0 Legal Summaries 0 Advisory Opinions 0 Reports 0 Resolutions 0 Ex
57. t s case law importance level 3 For importance 3 judgments and decisions delivered from 1 January 2007 onwards only the following fields are operational for searches concerning this category Case Title Application Number State Article Keywords Conclusion Text Importance level Only cases of importance levels 1 and 2 contain a full analysis and can be searched under all the fields 3 State Use the State filter to search for cases against a particular country or countries The filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents containing the respondent State or States 12 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights When you click on More the list of States is displayed in alphabetical order You can sort the State filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order 4 Article Use the Article filter to search by the Convention or Protocol Article s concerned in a case Simply follow the format in the table below to filter by Article To search for Selec Article 8 8 Article 6 5 3 d Article 2 of Protocol No 1 Article 14 in conjunction with Article 3 This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents containing the Article When you click on More the list of Articles is displayed in order of their appeara
58. the text Examples Christos Rozakis Nicolas Bratza etc The filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents containing the judge s name When you click on More the judges names are displayed in alphabetical order You can sort the Judges filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order 4 Originating Body Use the Originating Body filter to search for documents emanating from a specific organ of the Court or Commission or from the Committee of Ministers Examples COMMISSION Plenary Committee of Ministers Court First Section etc This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents by originating body When you click on More the Originating Body filter is displayed in alphabetical order You can sort the Originating Body filter by alphabetical order reverse alphabetical order number of results in descending order number of results in ascending order 19 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights 5 Organisation Use the Organisation filter to search by national and international organisations mentioned in the texts Examples European Central Bank Council of Europe Air Canada etc This filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents containing references to the national and international organisations When you click on More th
59. tions joined to merits and dismissed x x x Preliminary objection partially joined to merits and dismissed x Preliminary objections partially joined to merits and dismissed x x x Preliminary objection not necessary to examine x Preliminary objections not necessary to examine x X X Preliminary objection withdrawn x Admissibility Remainder inadmissible Loss of victim status Inapplicable Lack of jurisdiction Struck out of the list Revision admitted Revision rejected 23 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Violation No violation Violation No violation of Article z Violation No violation of Article 2 2 Violation No violation of Article 14 z Violation No violation of Article 1 of Protocol No 1 Violation No violation of Article z read in the light of Article z TIP Depending on the case we add the following information substantive or procedural aspect potential violation non violation the State against which a violation or no violation has been found the State to which the applicant is liable to be or has been expelled or extradited etc For example No violation of Article 3 Prohibition of torture Article 3 Expulsion potential Serbia Just satisfaction and execution of judgments Damage claim dismissed Damage award Pecuniary and non pecuniary damage award Pecuniary damage claim dismissed Pecuniary damage award Pecuniary damage reserved Pecuniary d
60. tle A Z alphabetical order by title Title Z A reverse alphabetical order by title Case Tithe 2 4 State 4 2 state 4 4 App Number Ascending App Number Descending State A Z alphabetical order by respondent State Date Newest then State State Z A reverse alphabetical order by respondent State Date Oldest then State Application Number Ascending numerical order by application number Application Number Descending reverse numerical order by application number Date Newest then State Sort by Date then by State Date Oldest then State Sort by Date then by State 12012 29 HUDOC EEE VIII The results list screen In this example we are looking for Judgments Grand Chamber and Chamber in English Importance level 1 No violation of Article 8 and Keyword Art 8 1 Respect for family life DOCUMENT COLLECTIONS El w Case Law 62 EM Judgments 62 Iw Grand Chamber 17 v Chamber 45 Committee 0 Decisions 0 Admissibility 0 Screening Panel 0 Communicated Cases 0 Legal Summaries 0 Advisory Opinions 0 Reports 0 Resolutions 0 Execution 0 Merits 0 11111 Press Collection FILTERS LANGUAGE IMPORTANCE English 62 x 1 62 x Case Reports 23 More STATE ARTICLE France 12 amp 1 62 United Kingdom 8 62 8 8 2 40 Netherlands 7 41 27 taly 8 More NON VIOLATION VIOLA
61. ts with similar legal content keywords are linked to the Court s reasoning and conclusions The Keywords filter is displayed in descending order of the number of documents containing the keyword in respect of the Article indicated On the left hand side of the KEYWORDS 4 5 screen you can narrow your Art 8 Right to a fair trial 17470 search with keywords Art 41 Just satisfaction 4 generar 16325 Art 6 1 Reasonable time 7901 Number of documents Art 6 Civil proceedings 6913 in brackets When you click More the list of 5 is displayed by Article in the order of appearance of the Articles of the Convention and additional Protocols There are two main ways to locate a keyword First by navigating through the hierarchy via and H icons Second by entering a search term in the field at the top of the window and performing a search of the entire hierarchy 15 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights Art 1 Obligation to respect human rights 87 Art 2 Right to life 1127 Art 3 Prohibition of torture 2884 Art 4 Prohibition of slavery and forced labour 80 Art 5 Right to liberty and security 3367 Art 6 Right to a fair trial 17108 Art 7 punishment without law 191 and family life 2597 Art 8 rt 9 Tick the box nce and religion 324 eneral 1583 Art T UT azzEITIDh azsociatio
62. ttp www echr coe int echr rss aspx You can also subscribe to eleven Notes plus an annual Index in paper version for 30 or US 45 More information can be found on this page http www echr coe int ECHR EN ECHR Publications Information notes on the Cour ts case law Information Note Home page G Viewing Press Releases Press releases are available from the results list CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY 14737 08 Judgment Meritt and Just Satisfaction Court Second Section 12 07 2011 Preliminary objection dismissed non exhaustion of domestic remedies Violation of Art amp No violation of Art Remainder in more C 5 Details Legal Summary Language Versions Fress Re Press Release and by clicking on the Related link 40 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights CASE OF SNEERSONE AND KAMPANELLA v ITALY 1473709 Judgment Merits and Just Satisfaction Court Second Section 12 07 2011 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 001 105624 View Case Details Language Versions Related Related Related English Documents Legal Summaries Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy Press Releases English press releases Sneersone and Kampanella v Italy 12 07 11 Announce judgments 12 07 11 In the Case Related French Documents Chamber Judgments AFFAIRE SNEERSONE ET KAMPANELLA c ITALIE Legal Summaries Sneersone and Kampanella c Italie
63. y are published in HUDOC for information purposes only and the Court accepts no responsibility for their Russian Translation Translations into non official languages Non official translations available Documents and tools provid Click on each language for a link to the translated text holds the copyright Please note that more than one translati Some of these translations may also be accessed via the Council of Europe s Internet site number of handbooks on Convention case lav and related glossaries are available in various languages Likewise E training tools on the Convention are provided in a variety of languages documents and tools provided by the Council of Europe and third parties documents and tools provided by the Court any non official translations available and links to third party Internet sites that host other translations of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights 34 HUDOC HUDOC Manual European Court of Human Rights CASE OF KLAAS v GERMANY 15473 89 Judgment Merits Court Chamber 22 09 1993 Document URL http hudoc echr coe int sites eng pages search aspx i 001 57826 View Case Details Language Versions Related Bt e External on line collections of translations A series of links is provided below to Internet sites hosting translations of Convention case law into languages other than English and French This list is not exhaustive Please note The Court is

HUDOC User Manual 1.0

Contents

Download Pdf Manuals

Related Search

Related Contents